Added: Jan 13, 2008

From: lana1912

Duration: 9:59

Who is the best Idol ever? Vote for your favorite by posting comments!

Channel: Music

Tags: american  best  carnival  carrie  clarkson  december  idol  kelly  leona  lewis  music  my  ride  spirit  underwood  vote  x-factor 


Rating: 4.28 (32 ratings)    Views: 4237' favoriteCount='18    Comments: 235

ankatz Says:

Aug 5, 2008 - simon says a lot of crap.

SurferBoy8708 Says:

Aug 6, 2008 - o get over yourself kelly did it all by yourself whether the fuck you like it or not dipshit,simon cowell knows a hell of alot more then your pathetic ass,it was AMERICAN IDOL not WORLDWIDE IDOL she did all by herself dont hate bitch kelly is the best

SurferBoy8708 Says:

Aug 6, 2008 - she did it all by herself and thats the truth,if u dont believe it then your a dumb fuck haha,get a life hata,kelly became a worldwide superstar without idol

SurferBoy8708 Says:

Aug 6, 2008 - xoxmellymel LOL NICE SN LOL,get over it bitch you stop hating to,and strop trying to make up excuses and say kelly cant sing really is that why she got praised by EVERYONE celebritys and everything before she even won idol,type in Miss Kelly Clarkson it will bring it up see 4 yourself bitch,kelly is the best outta the 3 but i think u mean kelly and leona SMASH carrie,that make her look like such a amatuer,seriously,type in Moto 9 Kelly Mentions its celebs praisin kellys voice it was in 2007

jwobble44 Says:

Aug 7, 2008 - i agree totally

jwobble44 Says:

Aug 7, 2008 - Leona has the best voice but carrie has more success. ppl dont realize that cause there so clueless to the country music world.

musiclover872008 Says:

Aug 7, 2008 - carrie has more succes of leona yes but not more successful then kelly,sorry kelly wins on both being more succesful and way better vocally

ankatz Says:

Aug 8, 2008 - ah no. kelly would have been in texas now without idol as her house burned down when she got to la. so without idol she would never gotten where she is. as least carrie has the balls to admit it.

ankatz Says:

Aug 8, 2008 - what the fuck does simon know, he runs his mouth, he didnt like kelly clarkson in the beginning, kelly even admitted he didnt remember her past her first audition. when she had her success two years ago he was like, oh best idol ever. now she dropped and hes back to liking carrie again. he remembered Carrie though, always wanted her to win during her season.

carolinagirl009 Says:

Aug 8, 2008 - Yeah only because Carrie has been out longer than Leona so. But no of them are more successful world-wide than Kelly. There are people in some parts of the world who even don't know who Carrie is.

cardude527 Says:

Aug 9, 2008 - This needs to be update because Carrie and Leona have new stuff out (singles and videos)

saxysaxist Says:

Aug 9, 2008 - Besides, the only reason why Simon praises Leona over Kelly is because Leona is signed to his record company. Of course he would want to promote Leona so his record company to make more money.

yea2yea Says:

Aug 10, 2008 - ok first of all, Leona is a one hit wonder. i mean i like her voice and such but it's not all that.so she's out of the competition.then carrie and kelly. i wouldn't compare those two cuz they're both equally great but i lean more towards kelly because not only does kelly have a more powerful tone and range than carrie but she's also versatile. the only types of songs i've seen carrie sing is Pop or country types. Kelly can do more than that she doe country,R&B,pop-rock adn so much more.

futurstarprince Says:

Aug 11, 2008 - carrie

GoldenSun96 Says:

Aug 15, 2008 - leona lewis WILL be more succesful than carrie AND kelly.You Watch :)

SurferBoy8708 Says:

Aug 15, 2008 - haha no she wont sorry,if shes lucky she MIGHT give carrie a run for a money but DOUPT IT but she will NEVER EVER be more succesful then Kelly Clarkson,so get over it leona sucks,end of story,hahahahaha

Tristanrocksmore Says:

Aug 16, 2008 - carrie, all the way.

9musiclover9 Says:

Aug 16, 2008 - And where exactly are your sources...?

9musiclover9 Says:

Aug 16, 2008 - "kelly would not have been able to go worldwide without the exposure of american idol. no way, no how."Same for Carrie, oh, whoops. She isn't worldwide anyway.

jennymar Says:

Aug 23, 2008 - Why is that you think?

LyssaLynn98 Says:

Aug 23, 2008 - why is there even a question?carrie is first,then kelly,and leona,she is so-so

abcsweet Says:

Aug 25, 2008 - they all can def sing circles around the average signed artist today. they are all sopranos spinto sopranos actually. one is country, one is pop and one is contemp/r&B

KellyFan4Lyfe08 Says:

Aug 27, 2008 - Ryan Tedder recently spoke with ABC News Radio heres what he had to say bout Kelly Clarksons 4th CD,due in November,Tedder did quite a bit of work on Kellys 4th CD,when asked to describe it,Tedder said its amazing.He added,She was talkin about how she thinks it'll be better than any album shes put out so far.The last song we did together is my favorite song Ive ever done,Its very haunting.Tedder raves,Ive never been more excited about material that Ive worked on with any artist,to be quite frank

hmoob4life Says:

Sep 6, 2008 - Kelly Kelly Kelly

Hrvaticaaaaa14 Says:

Sep 6, 2008 - Leona Lewis!!